OklahomaSports.Net is pleased to present the third annual All-OSN Softball Teams for Division II and NAIA.
| NCAA Division II | ||
| Coach of the Year | John Martin | Central |
| Player of the Year | Alex Pimentel | Southwestern |
| Pitcher of the Year | Caleb Bly | Oklahoma Baptist |
| First Team | ||
| P | Spencer Bivens | Rogers State |
| P | Caleb Bly | Oklahoma Baptist |
| P | Walker Wharton | Northwestern |
| RP | Jake Collins | Oklahoma Christian |
| C | Juan Gonzalez | Oklahoma Baptist |
| 1B | Paul Kropf | Central |
| 2B | Kyle Miskovsky | Central |
| SS | Alex Pimentel | Southwestern |
| 3B | Zane Gelphman | Oklahoma Baptist |
| OF | Brett Berghammer | Oklahoma Baptist |
| OF | Jake Dyer | Central |
| OF | Bryan Miranda | Southwestern |
| DH | Joseph Cerda | Southeastern |
| Second Team | ||
| P | Dustin Berrong | Northeastern State |
| P | Zach Fowler | Oklahoma Baptist |
| P | Tyler Culver | Central |
| RP | Josh Rutland | Central |
| C | Cole Williams | Cameron |
| 1B | Austin Ferguson | Southeastern |
| 2B | Brady Burtner | Southwestern |
| SS | Zack Mann | Rogers State |
| 3B | Brett Akins | Southeastern |
| OF | Jake Gozzo | Oklahoma Baptist |
| OF | Hunter Markwardt | Oklahoma Christian |
| OF | Cale Ridling | East Central |
| DH | Blake Chiaramonte | Rogers State |
| NAIA | ||
| Coach of the Year | Matt Parker | Oklahoma Wesleyan |
| Player of the Year | Lane Milligan | Oklahoma City |
| Pitcher of the Year | Tyson Cronin | Oklahoma Wesleyan |
| First Team | ||
| P | Tyson Cronin | Oklahoma Wesleyan |
| P | Bryce Milligan | Oklahoma City |
| P | Keisy Portorreal | Mid-America Christian |
| RP | Angel Reyes | USAO |
| C | Lane Milligan | Oklahoma City |
| 1B | Slayton Vaughan | Southwestern Christian |
| 2B | Kenniel Rivera | USAO |
| SS | P.J. Garcia | USAO |
| 3B | Austin Sojka | Oklahoma Wesleyan |
| OF | Hunter Aguirre | Oklahoma City |
| OF | Diogen Ceballos | Southwestern Christian |
| OF | Daniel Costello | Oklahoma City |
| DH | Joe Lytle | Oklahoma City |
| Second Team | ||
| P | Kyle Fimbrez | Oklahoma Wesleyan |
| P | Jose Hidalgo | USAO |
| P | Ryan Sandler | Oklahoma Wesleyan |
| RP | Tanner Andrews | Oklahoma City |
| C | Coleton Horner | USAO |
| 1B | Hunter Henry | Oklahoma Wesleyan |
| 2B | Nick McGrew | Oklahoma Wesleyan |
| SS | Felix Martinez | Mid-America Christian |
| SS | Anthony Ward | Southwestern Christian |
| 3B | Miguel Lorenzo | USAO |
| OF | Colton Kelly | Oklahoma Wesleyan |
| OF | John Lantigua | Oklahoma Wesleyan |
| OF | Diego Pichardo | Mid-America Christian |
| DH | Ryan Lujan-Leonard | Oklahoma Wesleyan |