| First Team | ||||
| Name | School | Pos. | Yr. | Hometown |
| Kathleen Daniel | Brenau (Ga.) | P | Fr. | Locust Grove, Ga. |
| Georgia Wall* | Oklahoma City | P | So. | Marlow, Okla. |
| Abby Meador*^ | Oklahoma City | P | Jr. | Midwest City, Okla. |
| Jaci Smith* | Oklahoma City | C | So. | Godley, Texas |
| Kelsey Connolly | Thomas (Ga.) | C | Jr. | Lodi, Ca. |
| Kali Pugh* | Oklahoma City | INF | Sr. | Vista, Calif. |
| Erin Sharpe | Bellevue (Neb.) | INF | So. | Bosque Farms, N.M. |
| Madison Ellis* | Oklahoma City | INF | Sr. | Yukon, Okla. |
| Molly Carter | Columbia (Mo.) | INF | So. | Columbia, Mo. |
| Julinn Torres* | LSU Alexandria (La.) | INF | Sr. | El Paso, Texas |
| Niki Cook | Georgia Gwinnett | OF | Jr. | Buford, Ga. |
| Carly Spalding^ | Columbia (Mo.) | OF | Sr. | Monroe City, Mo. |
| Tara Moates^ | Oregon Tech | OF | Jr. | Klamath Falls, Ore. |
| Aubri Hockenbury | Houston-Victoria (Texas) | OF | Sr. | Santa Fe, Texas |
| Kaisey Carson* | Indiana Wesleyan | UTIL | Sr. | Avon, Ind. |
| Dani Billings | LSU Alexandria (La.) | DP | Jr. | Nixa, Mo. |
| Breena Smith | Marian (Ind.) | At-LP | So. | Indianapolis, Ind. |
| Morghan Dieringer | St. Francis (Ill.) | At-LP | Jr. | New Lenox, Ill. |
| Kelli Fisher | Bellevue (Neb.) | At-LP | Sr. | Yutan, Neb. |
| Brashante Dareus | Georgia Gwinnett | ALINF | Sr. | Freeport, Bahamas |
| Second Team | ||||
| Name | School | Pos. | Hometown | |
| Kelsey Conkey | Rio Grande (Ohio) | P | So. | Minford, Ohio |
| Rachel Henks | Morningside (Iowa) | P | Sr. | Lee’s Summit, Mo. |
| Claudia Farrell*^ | Grand View (Iowa) | P | Jr. | Des Moines, Iowa |
| Kelsey Gravens | Midway (Ky.) | C | Jr. | Mt. Washington, Ky. |
| Destiny Turner^ | College of Idaho | C | Sr. | Boise, Idaho |
| Madison Wright | Simpson | INF | So. | Carlisle, Iowa |
| Taylor Braselton | Reinhardt (Ga.) | INF | Sr. | Euharlee, Ga. |
| Jacqueline Roof* | Campbellsville (Ky.) | INF | Jr. | Paducah, Ky. |
| Kyndle Wolfinger | Siena Heights (Mich.) | INF | Sr. | Jackson, Mich. |
| Michaela Criner | Rio Grande (Ohio) | INF | Fr. | Lancaster, Ohio |
| Michaela Shouldis | Oklahoma Wesleyan | OF | Jr. | Dayton, Ore. |
| Kayla Prachyl | Texas Wesleyan | OF | Jr. | Ennis, Texas |
| Samantha Stallbaumer | Oklahoma City | OF | So. | Haven, Kan. |
| Megan Washam | Evangel | OF | Sr. | Corinth, Texas |
| Taylor Winn* | Lindenwood-Belleville | UTIL | Sr. | Herrin, Ill. |
| Theresa DeCosty | Columbia (Mo.) | DP | Sr. | St. Charles, Mo. |
| Jessie Isham | Corban (Ore.) | At-LC | So. | Salem, Ore. |
| Molli Morgan | Ottawa (Kan.) | At-LP | Sr. | Paola, Kan. |
| Madison Byrd | Tabor (Kan.) | At-LP | Fr. | Stanton, Calif. |
| Marci West | LSU Alexandria (La.) | At-LP | Sr. | Anacoco, La. |
Honorable Mention
| Name | School |
| Marinna Shadley | Ave Maria |
| Olivia Brees | Baker (Kan.) |
| Sarah Crews | Clarke |
| Sabrina Boyd | Corban (Ore.) |
| Iris Rodriguez | Corban (Ore.) |
| Alexa Flores | Davenport |
| McKenzie Kenobbie | Dickinson State |
| Laykyn Lindsay | Friends (Kan.) |
| Devin Brown | Grand View (Iowa) |
| Kelsey Brodbeck | Keiser (Fla.) |
| Casey Bryan | Lindsey Wilson (Ky.) |
| Grace Lumpkin | Marian (Ind.) |
| Caylee Porter | Martin Methodist (Tenn.) |
| Kassidy Butler | Michigan Dearborn |
| Mallory Land | Park (Mo.) |
| Alexis Paulo-Meyers | Peru State (Neb.) |
| Tate Landmark | Science & Arts |
| Kelsey Randall | Southern Oregon |
| Chelsie Valentine | Warner (Fla.) |
| Rachel Hickman | William Carey (Miss.) |
Player of the Year: Kali Pugh, Oklahoma City
Pitcher of the Year: Kathleen Daniel, Brenau (Ga.)
* 2016 All-American
^2015 All-American